Trending

HolidayGift GuideBalloonsNew & Now

Categories

Clearance
Sign In
Pickup Store: 
  • Careers
  • Our Company
  • Philanthropy
  • Press Kit
  • Investor Relations
  • Gift Cards
  • Find a Store Near You!

About Us

  • Careers
  • Our Company
  • Philanthropy
  • Press Kit
  • Investor Relations
  • Gift Cards
  • Find a Store Near You!
  • Customer
  • Crew
  • Applicant
  • FAQ
  • Order Status

Support

  • Customer
  • Crew
  • Applicant
  • FAQ
  • Order Status
  • Terms of Use
  • Five Below Privacy Policy
  • Consumer Privacy Supplemental Information
  • About Ads
  • CA Supply Chain
  • Product Recalls
  • Accessibility Statement

Legal

  • Terms of Use
  • Five Below Privacy Policy
  • Consumer Privacy Supplemental Information
  • About Ads
  • CA Supply Chain
  • Product Recalls
  • Accessibility Statement
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Download Our Apps!

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

By registering you agree to Five Below's terms of use and privacy policies

© 2026 Five Below. All Rights Reserved.

The Sweet Tooth

  1. /
  2. Holiday
  3. /
  4. Stocking Stuffers
  5. /
  6. The Sweet Tooth
Filter By
157 Results
  1. ‌
    4 for $5Holiday Nerds® Rope Candy
    Holiday Nerds® Rope Candy

    $1.50

    In Stock for Shipping

  2. ‌
    4 for $5Haribo® Sweet & Sour Reindeer Gummies
    Haribo® Sweet & Sour Reindeer Gummies

    $1.50

    In Stock for Shipping

  3. ‌
    The Grinch™ Dr.Seuss™ Hot Cocoa Bomb 1.3oz
    The Grinch™ Dr.Seuss™ Hot Cocoa Bomb 1.3oz

    $5.00

    In Stock for Shipping

  4. ‌
    4 for $5Tic Tac® Naughty Or Nice Candy Cane Flavored Mints 0.8oz
    Tic Tac® Naughty Or Nice Candy Cane Flavored Mints 0.8oz

    $1.50

    In Stock for Shipping

  5. ‌
    The Grinch Hershey's Kisses® Candy Tube
    The Grinch Hershey's Kisses® Candy Tube

    $3.00

    In Stock for Shipping

  6. ‌
    2 for $5Oreo Hot Cocoa Mix
    Oreo Hot Cocoa Mix

    $3.00

    In Stock for Shipping

  7. ‌
    4 for $5The Elf On The Shelf™ Double Crisp Candy 3oz
    The Elf On The Shelf™ Double Crisp Candy 3oz

    $1.50

    In Stock for Shipping

  8. ‌
    4 for $5Peeps® Marshmallow Holiday Green Trees 3-Pack
    Peeps® Marshmallow Holiday Green Trees 3-Pack

    $1.50

    In Stock for Shipping

  9. ‌
    4 for $5Sour Patch Kids® Holiday Candy 3.1oz
    Sour Patch Kids® Holiday Candy 3.1oz

    $1.50

    In Stock for Shipping

  10. ‌
    4 for $5Palmer® Double Crisp Coal® Chocolate Bag
    Palmer® Double Crisp Coal® Chocolate Bag

    $1.50

    In Stock for Shipping

  11. ‌
    Holiday Reese's® Miniatures Candy-Filled Candy Cane
    Holiday Reese's® Miniatures Candy-Filled Candy Cane

    $3.00

    In Stock for Shipping

  12. ‌
    4 for $5Sour Patch Kids® Coal Black Raspberry Theater Box Candy 3.1oz - Holiday Theme
    Sour Patch Kids® Coal Black Raspberry Theater Box Candy 3.1oz - Holiday Theme

    $1.50

    In Stock for Shipping

  13. ‌
    Sour Patch Kids Santa & Elves
    Sour Patch Kids Santa & Elves

    $4.00

    In Stock for Shipping

  14. ‌
    2 for $5Krabby Patties Gummy Filled Candy Cane
    Krabby Patties Gummy Filled Candy Cane

    $3.00

    In Stock for Shipping

  15. ‌
    4 for $5Haribo® Goldbears® Gummi Candy Holiday Edition 4oz Bag
    Haribo® Goldbears® Gummi Candy Holiday Edition 4oz Bag

    $1.50

    In Stock for Shipping

  16. ‌
    2 for $5Reindeer Snot Green Apple Candy Slime
    Reindeer Snot Green Apple Candy Slime

    $3.00

    In Stock for Shipping

  17. ‌
    4 for $5Peeps® Marshmallow Holiday Snowmen 3-Pack
    Peeps® Marshmallow Holiday Snowmen 3-Pack

    $1.50

    In Stock for Shipping

  18. ‌
    2 for $5Nik-L-Nip® Elf Punch Mini Drinks 2.7oz
    Nik-L-Nip® Elf Punch Mini Drinks 2.7oz

    $3.00

    In Stock for Shipping

  19. ‌
    Nerds® Juicy Blizzard Punch Gummy Cluster
    Nerds® Juicy Blizzard Punch Gummy Cluster

    $5.00

    In Stock for Shipping

  20. ‌
    Amos® Peelerz® Gummy Candy 6oz
    Amos® Peelerz® Gummy Candy 6oz

    $4.00

    In Stock for Shipping

  21. ‌
    Nerds Frosty Flavor Gummy Clusters
    Nerds Frosty Flavor Gummy Clusters

    $5.00

    In Stock for Shipping

  22. ‌
    Smarties® Squashies Raspberry And Cream 5oz
    Smarties® Squashies Raspberry And Cream 5oz

    $3.00

    In Stock for Shipping

You've viewed 22 of 157 products

Load More Products
Fill every stocking with Christmas stocking candy from Five Below. Our candy for Christmas stockings includes M&M'S®, Haribo®, Peeps®, Pez®, and Kinder Joy™, all in sizes that slip right in next to the gifts. With so many affordable picks, you can give each stocking its own sweet mix.

Candy for Stocking Stuffers by Type
Pick a little from each group for the best Christmas candy for stockings:
  • •Chocolate: The Ferrero Rocher® Hollow Chocolate Santa, The Grinch Hershey's Kisses® Candy Tube, and BeeMax® Dubai Style Chocolate. Find more Christmas chocolate.
  • •Gummies and sour candy: Haribo® Sweet & Sour Reindeer Gummies, Sour Patch Kids Santa & Elves, Trolli Snowmen, and Nerds Frosty Flavor Gummy Clusters.
  • •Novelty candy: Holiday Pez® Candy & Dispenser, Peeps® Marshmallow Holiday Snowmen, the Holiday Reese's® Miniatures Candy-Filled Candy Cane, and the TastySounds Audio Lollipop. Browse more candy canes.

All of these make easy candy for stocking stuffers, especially when you mix textures and flavors.

Assortment and styles vary by store and online. Prices subject to change.
See the full holiday gift guide catalog for everything in this year's lineup.

Stocking Candy for Kids and Adults
For kids: Character candy and fun formats win here. The Elf On The Shelf® Chocolate Figure, Holiday Pez® Candy & Dispenser, Kinder Joy™ Egg With Surprise Toy & Treat, and Baby Bottle Pop® Christmas Candy all pull double duty as candy and a little toy.
For adults: Go for chocolate and bold flavors. Grand Ferrero Rocher, Galerie Au Chocolat® Dubai Style Truffles, Swedish Bubs® Sour Skalle™, and Harry Potter™ Butterbeer™ Chewy Candy make grown-up stockings candy feel like a treat. A Palmer® Double Crisp Coal® Chocolate Bag is a fun joke for anyone who landed on the naughty list.

Christmas Stocking Candy FAQs

What is the best candy for Christmas stockings?
The best candy for Christmas stockings is small, individually wrapped, and festive. Holiday-themed chocolate, gummies shaped like reindeer or snowmen, and candy-filled candy canes are easy picks, and mixing a few types keeps every stocking interesting.

What is the most popular Christmas candy?
Chocolate, candy canes, and gummies are some of the most popular Christmas candy every year. At Five Below, holiday favorites include Hershey's Kisses®, M&M'S®, Ferrero Rocher®, and Peeps®. Shop all our Christmas candy for more.

How much candy should go in a stocking?
A good rule of thumb is three to five pieces of Christmas stocking stuffer candy per stocking. Mix smaller fun-size candies near the toe with a larger candy cane or chocolate figure peeking out of the top. Adding non-candy gifts keeps the stocking balanced so treats don't completely take over.

For non-candy picks, browse our stocking stuffer ideas, pick up new Christmas stockings, and check out our dollar gifts for more small add-ons.